Me and Viliam On: Intersectionality and Insight
Below I reproduce a short exchange I had with frequent LessWrong commenter Viliam last week on this thread . Some thoughts on the thread in retrospect: I come from a position in stark opposition to 'intersectionality' and similar notions arising from critical theory, and would ordinarily be content to dismiss it out of hand. However, in the recent past I've had to reconsider a similar position regarding the whole body of postmodern philosophy and related studies, owing to the writings of David Chapman (see this article and this comment ), which find part of their base in postmodern and critical figures, most prominently Heidegger and Foucault, and make the case that those thinkers were, in fact, very careful and profound, but that their insights were diluted both by the fashionable nonsense styles they wrote in and by their successors, who were not trained in the Western rational corpus before attempting to reform (or destroy) it. This by no means invalidates criticisms ...